LORNA PARTINGTON WALSH

  • HOME
  • EDITING
  • Writers Workshop
  • Meet Lorna
    • Clients
    • Testimonials
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • HOME
  • EDITING
  • Writers Workshop
  • Meet Lorna
    • Clients
    • Testimonials
  • Contact
  • Blog

Books with Spine
​The Blog

Authenticity in Fiction

6/9/2022

1 Comment

 
PicturePhoto by Markus Winkler on Unsplash
Every writer, at some point, has been told to ‘write what you know.’ The advice has become cliched, but lately it has been the focus of a debate that’s raging in the literary world: should writers (especially cis, straight, white, middleclass ones) be creating characters and stories that are outside of their lived experience? In other words, should certain writers be limited to autobiographical fiction (‘autofiction’)?

This debate continued at this year’s Hay Festival, reported in The Guardian this week, with contributions from authors Rose Tremain, Anna Lloyd Banwo, Kate Mosse, and Damon Galgut. The consensus among experienced authors is that you can ‘write what you like, but do it well,’ which means the following:
  • doing proper research
  • building community trust
  • having the skills to write something challenging
  • leaning on sensitivity readers to spot unconscious bias
 
But what does it mean for the many emerging authors without the publishing deals or means to do any of the above?
 
Authors may have the best intentions when creating characters or stories to which they cannot personally relate. However, ALL writers should be aware that we live in more sensitive but less forgiving times. There are those who seek out reasons to be offended (usually on behalf of other people!), and then there are people who, due to a history of oppression, have every right to take issue with the appropriation or misrepresentation of their culture, struggles or experiences. It’s this latter group that every writer must care about most.
 
Of course, anyone can self-publish anything, so long as they’re willing to accept the backlash from readers who feel the author got it wrong. But writers who aim to get an agent or traditional publisher should steer clear of straying too far from their own experience. Or, if they do, they must scrutinize their work through as honest a lens as possible. Some of the questions they might ask themselves are:

  • What is my motivation for writing about this culture/community? Is my motivation in any way ‘virtue signalling’ or based on assumptions/preconceptions?
  • Do I have sufficient connection or access to the culture/community to write with authenticity and to draw on qualified sensitivity readers?
  • How well do I understand the heritage of the culture/community I’m writing about (even if that doesn’t feature in the story)?
  • Does my character/story exist in their own right or do they ‘speak for’ the entire culture/community? (In other words, am I treating my characters as archetypes or stereotypes and writing stories that fit certain expectations?)
 
Personally, as a writer, I never step too far outside my comfort zone when creating protagonists and stories. I have written from different perspectives, such as male or older person’s viewpoint, and have included minor characters from other cultures/communities in stories. But overall, my key characters are always people I can easily imagine myself being, and the situations I put them in are always ones I can see myself in. My work is very much rooted in my worldview.

Nevertheless, I did have one potentially tricky moment as an author. I wrote a story that was published in a journal and the publication commissioned artwork for it. The illustrator depicted my protagonist as black, when in my mind they had been white (although the only hint of race, to be fair, was their Irish surname). The problem was that the character was a drug dealer, so I was worried that readers might see the image and accuse me of stereotyping. I'm sure the artist had the best intentions, but I would have preferred to avoid any potential for controversy!
 
Speaking as a professional editor, it is not always possible to edit within my natural comfort zone. As an editor who is cis, white, middle class, straight, neurotypical and non-disabled (yeah, I am that vanilla!), I am aware of my own limitations when editing for people from cultures or communities that I have no intimacy with. I would certainly decline a project if I felt unable to edit with sufficient sensitivity, but mostly I relish opportunities to enter fictional or nonfictional worlds portraying a different life experience. Some of the most memorable and affecting books I have edited are written by and about people who have lived very different lives to mine, and the objectivity I bring as an ‘outsider’ is often helpful because I am able to identify where the writing can be clearer or more inclusive to readers from a different background to the author.
 
Ultimately, authors have a responsibility to write the truth. In the case of fiction, this doesn’t mean novels or stories must always be autobiographical; it simply means the world, the situations, the relationships, and the emotions that a writer creates in their fiction must be authentic. And once you have truth on your side, your imagination can run free!

1 Comment
Tina Gharavi
7/7/2022 05:59:23 pm

You're the best Lorna... Even thinking all this through as you have. Thanks for keeping this on your agenda and writing about it elegantly...

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Lorna Partington Walsh, Wordsmith

    Archives

    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018

    Categories

    All
    Book Review
    Editing Tips
    Memoir
    Nonprofit
    Opinion
    Publishing
    Social Entrepreneurship
    Spine Online
    Writing Tips

    RSS Feed

Copyright © 2022